This one is tough. I love my 3DS XL. I stood in line outside Target in -20 degree temperatures with my cousin for TWO hours as we missed the online pre-orders for the MM edition. So there is definitely some added value there.
On the other hand... The pros of the regular 3DS are enticing. More comfortable to hold, cover plates, and having a sharper image. I could probably trade off my XL for a regular version along with extras.
Anyone in the same boat?